When the Prophets Stopped
The Old Testament closes with a promise and a warning. God said He would send Elijah the prophet, and Malachi's last words are lest I come and smite the earth with a curse (Malachi 4:5–6). Then no prophet spoke. About four hundred years went by. One day in the temple an angel stood beside an old priest and picked up Malachi's sentence where it had stopped: to turn the hearts of the fathers to the children (Luke 1:17).
Those years are a gap in most people's knowledge of the Bible. When Malachi stops writing, Judah is a small province of Persia. When Matthew starts, Rome rules, Herod sits on the throne, and there are Pharisees, Sadducees, and synagogues that no one stops to explain. This study tells how the world got that way.
It is also a story about God. We call these the silent years, and the name is fair. God gave no new Scripture, and no prophet stood up with a fresh word from the LORD. But silent is not the same as absent. In those years God moved empires exactly as He had told Daniel He would. He kept His people through the worst persecution they had yet known. He kept His Word. And He set the stage for the day Paul calls the fulness of the time (Galatians 4:4).
The name often given to the roughly four hundred years between Malachi (about 435 to 420 BC) and John the Baptist. God sent no prophet and gave no new Scripture in those years. He did not stop ruling the nations or keeping His promises.
Why No Prophet?
Scripture does not give one stated reason. Through Malachi, God had rebuked a weary people who answered Him back at every turn, and Amos had warned long before of a famine of hearing the words of the LORD (Amos 8:11). But we know what God left them. His closing command was Remember ye the law of Moses my servant (Malachi 4:4). He had spoken, and what He had said was enough to live by until He spoke again.
Heaven's silence did not mean God had forgotten Israel. If He seems quiet in your own life today, take heart from these years, and see When God Feels Silent.
Loading the rest of this article
For Deeper Study
- The Four Hundred Silent YearsAmazon H. A. IronsideA short, readable walk from Malachi to Matthew by the dispensational Bible teacher and longtime pastor of Moody Church in Chicago.
- Daniel: The Key to Prophetic RevelationAmazon John F. WalvoordA dispensational, premillennial commentary that works through Daniel 8 and 11 verse by verse.
- The Antiquities of the JewsAmazon Flavius Josephus (trans. William Whiston)The first-century Jewish historian, and our main source for much of this story. Books 11 to 17 cover these years. Useful history, not Scripture.
- Foxe's Book of MartyrsAmazon John FoxeThe classic Protestant record of those who died for the faith, from the early church to the English Reformation.
As an Amazon Associate, Theologica earns from qualifying purchases.
Malachi
Malachi answers a weary, careless people with the LORD's unchanging love, rebukes their half-hearted worship, and promises the messenger and the Lord who are coming, the last word before four centuries of silence.
Open Doctrine