Study
Obeying God Rather than Men
Christian Ethics · Doctrinal study

Obeying God Rather than Men

When to say no to Caesar, and how to say it

Why It Matters

The Same Peter

Peter wrote, Submit yourselves to every ordinance of man for the Lord's sake (1 Peter 2:13). Peter also stood before the highest court of his people, under orders to stop preaching, and said, We ought to obey God rather than men (Acts 5:29). It was the same man, and he saw no contradiction. Neither should we.

All human authority is delegated. God ordained government, and He did not resign when He did. When a ruler stays within what God gave him, we obey for the Lord's sake (see Government and the Christian). When he commands what God forbids, or forbids what God commands, he has reached past his authority, and the believer must obey the One who gave it. Obedience is the normal posture. Refusal is the rare exception, and Christians take no pleasure in it.

DefinitionObeying God Rather Than Men

Refusing a particular command of a human authority because keeping it would mean disobeying God, while keeping every other duty, showing respect, and accepting the penalty. The word Peter used, peitharcheō, means to obey one in authority. He was saying that God outranks the court.

Three Questions Keep It Clear

  1. What must someone believe to be saved? The Gospel. No one is saved by courage, and a believer who has failed under pressure has not lost his Savior. Peter denied his Lord three times, wept bitterly (Luke 22:62), and was restored (John 21:17). If that is your story, this study is not written against you.
  2. What must a Christian believe and obey? The things no ruler can cancel: to worship God alone, to pray, to preach the Gospel, to gather with His people, and to refuse to take part in sin.
  3. Where has God granted liberty? Much of how this is carried out: whether to stay or to flee, how long to wait, which lawful remedy to try first, how a church gets through a crisis. Believers who agree on the line may differ on these, and they should not judge one another.
The Key Question

If the law of your land forbade what Jesus commands, what would you do, and how would you do it?

Loading the rest of this article

Further reading

For Deeper Study

As an Amazon Associate, Theologica earns from qualifying purchases.

Continue exploring

Government and the Christian

God ordained civil government to restrain evil and reward good, so Christians obey the law, pay their taxes, honor those in office, and pray for them, while knowing that no ruler owns the soul and no ruler can save.

Open Doctrine